Tile Roof Vs Composition Shingle

Shingle roofs shingles are the winner on price alone.

Tile roof vs composition shingle.

For cr s roofing tests we focus strictly on asphalt roofing shingles because they re by far the most common choice for roofs. A boon for folks with flat roofs the rolling roof revolution has impacted every shape of roof on today s market. Both will require less maintenance and last longer than asphalt. Composite tiles are the lightest while metal and clay tiles weigh more.

Shingle roofs are cheaper up front. If you are considering concrete roof tiles vs. Asphalt shingles will likely set you back somewhere between 3 00 to 5 00 per square foot while tile costs somewhat more with the price for material and installation coming in at anywhere from 4 00 to 5 55 per square foot. Tile is renewable and energy efficient like metal.

Like tile and shingle choices there s lots of variety in material including common rubber epdm recycled rubber sawdust and slate dust tpo polypropylene and ethylene propylene rubber and bitumen asphalt based. Clay roof tiles clay lasts longer than concrete. If your home is unable to support a heavy roof or you are unable to reinforce it then a shingle roof is the better. Now you can get nearly any style of roof shingle manufactured from metal.

Though you ll get more life out of a metal roof you ll pay the price at the time of installation. Metal roofing has come a long way. They last longer than genuine cedar shakes but cost about the same. Metal and asphalt versus tile and composite.

Tile and composite are two other options to consider for this project. Cost composite shingle roof cost ranges broadly from 7 75 to 14 50. When it comes to tile roofs vs. Composite roof shingles shakes and tiles are attractive and affordable alternatives to the real thing.

A concrete tile roof. Metal roofs generally can run from 120 to 900 per 100. Tile is more expensive than shingles usually at least double the price. However the life expectancy of tile ends up being about double that of shingles so it works out to be about even in that regard.

When comparing tile roofs and shingle roofs the first noticeable difference is the price. Here are a few of the most noteworthy differences. Composite tiles cost far less than genuine slate tiles and can last 50 years with proper installation. All tile roofs are heavier than a shingle roof however and require at least some degree of roof reinforcement leading to some of the high costs involved.

Composite is comparable to architectural asphalt shingles in price where tile is comparable to metal.